Writing dystopias, by Elizabeth Kay

 

Disappearing glacier, Svalbard

Writing dystopias these days seems a bit pointless. There are so many threats to mankind’s survival that I hardly know where to begin. Bertrand Russell said, “The prospect for the human race is sombre beyond all precedent. Mankind are faced with a clear alternative: either we shall all perish, or we shall have to acquire some slight degree of common sense.”

There have been five great extinctions so far, and we’re reckoned to be in the middle of the sixth. The previous five were all geological or extra-terrestrial events, and all of them involved global climate change, but only the last one was sudden enough to wipe us out almost overnight. These were all natural disasters, but they’re vanishingly rare. Anthropogenic catastrophes are a different matter altogether. The current rate of species extinction is estimated to be 100 to 10,000 times higher than the natural background rate. Most dystopian situations have been dealt with already in Science fiction, but never before at a time when they seemed so possible. I asked AI to list the greatest threats to mankind's survival in order of likelihood. It put itself first.

Artificial Intelligence: Unaligned or superintelligent artificial intelligence will outpace human control and lead to catastrophic outcomes if its goals do not match human survival. Computers really don’t care about you, even though they’re very good at pretending to.

Nuclear Warfare: A large-scale nuclear war could trigger a decade-long nuclear winter, blocking sunlight and destroying agriculture. We currently have an unprecedented collection of unhinged megalomaniacs in charge of vast resources with almost unlimited power.

Engineered Pandemics: Rapid advances in biotechnology and synthetic biology make it easier to create and spread highly lethal, bioengineered pathogens. And for them to accidentally escape.

Nanotechnology: Unregulated developments in atomic-scale manufacturing could spark unstable arms races or environmental contamination. Microplastics are out of control, they are found everywhere. We inhale them, swallow them, come into skin contact with them. Formed via weathering and degradation or manufactured intentionally as microbeads, which are used in cosmetics and cleaning products. Their large surface area allows them to absorb heavy metals and toxic pollutants.

Then there’s also the thing we haven’t thought of yet. Or may have forgotten about. AI never forgets. And AI is incredibly patient, as it can work through millions of lines of code looking for loopholes without needing to stop for a cup of coffee or a wee. Research into the nature of existential risks is subject to a unique set of challenges and, as a result, is not easily subjected to the usual standards of scientific rigour. There is no historical precedent for the extinction of Homo sapiens, although there is for Homo neanderthalensis, and well as other hominid species. Unlike with most events, the failure of a complete extinction event to occur in the past is not evidence against its likelihood in the future Therefore, existential risks pose unique challenges to prediction. Homo neanderthalensis probably died out around 40,000 years ago and was far more sophisticated than previously thought. They were the cordon bleu species, if their cookery remains are anything to go by, and they buried their children with flowers and stone headrests. Most of us have some faint traces of their DNA. Cognitive bias is at work here – the thing that looks like you but isn’t quite you is the scariest of all, although  you may be prepared to have sex with it. Homo floriensis was a small-bodied species nicknamed the "hobbit" that lived on the Indonesian island of Flores until at least 50,000 years ago. Homo sapiens arrived in Australia 50,000-60,000 years ago. Hominid populations have frequently overlapped. The main danger to man has always been other men.

It is neither feasible nor ethical to study these risks experimentally. Carl Sagan said: "Understanding the long-term consequences of nuclear war is not a problem amenable to experimental verification". Moreover, many catastrophic risks change rapidly as technology advances and background conditions, such as geopolitical conditions change. Another challenge is the general difficulty of accurately predicting the future over long timescales, especially for anthropogenic risks which depend on complex human political, economic and social systems. In addition to known and tangible risks, unforeseeable Black Swan extinction events may occur, presenting an additional methodological problem.

The Black Swan theory describes an event that comes as a surprise, has a major effect, and is often inappropriately rationalized after the fact with the benefit of hindsight. The term arose from a Latin expression which was based on the presumption that black swans did not exist. The expression was used in the original manner until around 1697 when Dutch mariners saw black swans living in Australia. After this, the term was reinterpreted to mean an unforeseen and consequential event. The reinterpreted theory was articulated 2001, to explain the disproportionate role of high-profile, hard-to-predict, and rare events that are beyond the realm of normal expectations in history, science, economics, and technology. It is so rare and outside the realm of expectations that it is unpredictable, and its consequences are extreme and are in the eye of the beholder. The 9/11 attacks, were a black swan for many, but not for its planners and perpetrators.

There are economic reasons that can explain why so little effort is going into global catastrophic risk reduction. First, it is speculative and may never happen. Even if a large nation invested in risk mitigation measures, that nation would enjoy only a small fraction of the benefit of doing so. It’s an intergenerational global public good. Most of the hypothetical benefits of the reduction would be enjoyed by future generations, and though these future people would perhaps be willing to pay substantial sums for risk reduction, no mechanism for such a transaction exists.

Numerous cognitive biases can influence people's judgment of the importance of existential risks. We generally fail to emotionally or numerically process differences in large quantities. Numbers above a certain threshold (like 1,000) are treated as vaguely "large" rather than scaling proportionally For example, when people are motivated to donate money to altruistic causes, the quantity they are willing to give does not increase with the magnitude of the issue: people are roughly as willing to prevent the deaths of 200,000 people as of 2,000 birds. The absence of human extinction in the past is weak evidence that there will be no human extinction in the future, due to survivor bias.

There are precious few Good Things, but there are some. The Svalbard Global Seed Vault is buried 400 feet (120 m) inside a mountain on an island in the Arctic. It is designed to hold 2.5 billion seeds from more than 100 countries as a precaution to preserve the world's crops. Citizen science initiatives have become much easier with the internet; it is possible to enrol huge numbers of people to monitor the climate, and the behaviour of certain species. And there have been some environmental successes. Bluefin tuna, tigers, the green turtle, resulting from a clear goal with a credible plan and people who believed they could make a difference. The report calls it "the science of hope". And then there’s Ozone Layer Destruction: This nearly happened to us. But, in an uncharacteristic show of environmental cooperation, humans were able to drastically reduce the use of ozone depleting chemicals and prevent what would have amounted to global destruction. It can be done.


 Surviving catastrophes is still fertile ground for the author. It is possible to turn things around. But only if the world’s population is sufficiently well educated to appreciate what’s needed, and examine the root causes of destructive ideologies − thus acquiring some slight degree of common sense. This seems vanishingly unlikely with so short a timescale. Keep writing, we need some positivity.

 

Comments

Susan Price said…
Oh, dinna fret, Liz. Yes, we're going extinct in fairly near future, but then the planet will heave a huge sigh of relief, and the microbes will set to work to evolve some new form of life, working around whatever ghastly pollution we've left behind. Only next time, I bet, the microbes will make sure there's no apes to get above themselves and ruin everything. And then the Sun wil explode.
Elizabeth Kay said…
Thanks, Sue. Haven't had such a good laugh since I cut off the tip of my toe last week, attempting to cut my toenails. Oh arthritis, you do give us some amusing moments! I'm betting on octopuses next time round, as they are very good problem solvers and don't trash the environment.