Climbing the Giants' shoulders: N M Browne

 

Recently someone asked what books I would recommend to someone intending to write fiction. I am a little ashamed to confess that I never read anything about writing before I started writing - it never occurred to me to do so. Looking back that seems both stupid and perverse and also entirely in character. 

There is an awful lot to be said for standing on the shoulders of giants, but all my life I have specialised in grubbing around in the shadows at their feet  messing up and making do, attempting to reinvent the wheel by trial and error. I know this isn't an intelligent approach. I've never learned to cook either in spite of the fact that I do a lot of it. I hate following recipes so my cooking is hit or miss and not infrequently a bit of both in a curate's egg kind of way. I am at a loss to explain this idiocy even to myself. I could have saved so much time and my family so many terrible culinary experiences if only I'd taken the time to master a couple of basic techniques. I know this and yet here I am still failing to take lessons, still blundering on.

I learned to write by reading, which makes a lot more sense than learning to cook by eating but is, I think, a little bit the same. I know what effect I want to create and then mash words together until I cook up something with  roughly the right flavour (don't worry I am not going to push this metaphor any further.) 

I wonder if I'd set out to approach writing in a more sensible way I might have been frightened off. I wonder if I'd have found the task too difficult and daunting because the only thing I can say in defence of my method is that it is impossible to get wrong: when you don't know the right way of doing things there is no wrong way. I think my whole failure to engage with other people's advice is part of a largely unconscious  effort to con my psyche into believing that novel writing is such a natural, easy process that no special skill or knowledge is necessary.

My own methodology that emerged through trial and error sometimes works and sometimes doesn't. If you are interested I explain it herehere and here

Perhaps now I have had some experience I could dare to read a book about writing without being scared off. I am finally considering learning how to cook - a momentous shift in attitude.  So, if you have any good suggestions I am eager to clamber up onto the shoulders of giants and not a moment too soon. What books would you recommend? 


Comments

Nick Garlick said…
The only book about writing that offered me any encouragement/help was Stephen King's On Writing. And even then I didn't follow all his advice. (And if nothing else, it's great read.)
Bill Kirton said…
I think you're being a bit hard on yourself, Nicky. Even though I’ve written such books myself (mostly aimed at helping students with their academic writing), I think to write effectively isn’t something that can be taught. Having the instinct to be a writer and the stamina to apply it means that you already are. We don’t all produce elegance, wit, even accuracy, but turning our experiences, hopes, dreams, fictions into pages or screenfuls of words is a satisfying pursuit, even if no one else reads them and we discard them the following day in disgust or despair. Most of your ‘giants’ probably had pretty full waste-paper baskets.
Susan Price said…
Nicki, I think you're better off looking up a few cooking techniques on Google (what I do when forced to cook something more than a boiled egg.)
After all, if you've written and published complete books and connected with an audience, you know how to write, however you got there.

I've enjoyed several books on writing -- 'Save the Cat!' comes to mind but I don't know that I've made any major changes to the way I write because of them, They remind me a bit of the way they used to teach painting and drawing as an 'accomplishment for young ladies.' -- "This is the way you do a tree. This is a way you do a cloud." Useful for an absolute beginner, but you have to go beyond that and you probably already have.

But Nick's right -- Stephen King does have some on-the-nail things to say. But we only know that because we already do it!
Peter Leyland said…
A post-modernist approach Nicki and I use that expression because I think it sounds clever! is learning to write by writing, the learning by doing approach that I always favoured with children.
Peter Leyland said…
Post-modern spelling too Nicky. Apologies.
Reb MacRath said…
Best book I ever read about writing was about--and entitled--On Reading Like a Writer by Francine Prose.
Wendy H. Jones said…
I would say you've cracked this writing lark. I Leo the purse grubbing around at their feet. It says it all
Umberto Tosi said…
I'm with Bill in urging you to go easy on yourself. Reading is actually the best way to learn how to write, followed closely by persistence in writing itself. Whatever works is my motto. I find memoirist books by writers more illuminating than manuals. Along those lines I recommend "Negotiating with the Dead: A Writer on Writing", by Margaret Atwood.