Forbidden Fruit - has it lost its power? wonders Griselda Heppel (between delicious mouthfuls)

I suppose it’s inevitable that on this glorious day of chocolate scoffing, of succumbing to all the temptations resisted (well, by some of us anyway) during the last few weeks, my mind should wander – or perhaps waddle – back to the role of delicious food in books.  But not in the nurturing, life-enhancing way I looked at last month; just the opposite. And while this works as a literary and moral device, it can be pretty cruel to your characters.

All downhill from here
To begin at the beginning… How does the serpent corrupt Eve in the Garden of Eden? With a crisp, juicy apple, thus setting in motion 2,000 years of imagery in which the poor apple takes the brunt of all the evil in the world. Interestingly the idea of fruit being a catalyst for trouble isn’t just a Judeo-Christian one: think of the six pomegranate seeds swallowed by Persephone when kidnapped by Hades, which bind her to the Underworld for half the year.
Golden Apple of Discord

Or the golden apple thrown by Eris, Greek goddess of discord, into the wedding of Thetis and Peleus, which reappears at the judgement of Paris, only for him to assign it to the wrong goddess and kickstart the Trojan War.

The Garden of Earthly Delights, as seen by Bosch

With such powerful religious and classical antecedents, no wonder the idea of Forbidden Fruit took such hold on the western imagination, a vein of wicked temptation running from the Garden of Earthly Delights of mediaeval literature to the yearning for apricots that betrays Webster's Duchess of Malfi to the clandestine plum pudding Edmund Gosse nibbles, in Father and Son

This last example is especially poignant, since it comes from a memoir, not fiction. A member of the puritan Plymouth Brethren, Gosse’s father believed the human pleasures associated with celebrating Christmas – singing, dancing, fine clothes and feasting – to be the work of the devil. Aghast that his little son should be so deprived, the maids feed him a slice of the plum pudding they’ve secretly made for themselves; his father, discovering the crime, ‘flung the idolatrous confectionery on to the middle of the [dust heap], and then raked it deep down into the mass.’

Idolatrous Confectionary

I find this scene heartbreaking to read. As Gosse himself writes, ‘The suddenness, the violence, the velocity of this extraordinary act made an impression on my memory which nothing will ever efface’ – all arising from a fear that what is enjoyable to the senses must by definition be sinful. Here is the exact opposite of the ‘speckled cannon ball…blazing in half of half-a-quartern of ignited brandy,’ that cheers the table of the hard-up Cratchit family in Dickens’s A Christmas Carol.

Christmas at the Cratchits
Indeed, while Dickens makes brilliant metaphorical use of natural phenomena (the fog in Bleak House, for instance, confusing and entrapping as the legal system; or the predatory Carker’s white teeth in Dombey and Son) he is the last writer to endow an apple, a pudding, or anything else with evil characteristics. There’s nothing like a poverty-stricken childhood to teach you the true value of food. It is hunger, not greed, that prompts Oliver to ask for more (Oliver Twist). Pip quakes in terror that his theft of a pie will be discovered; yet he stole not for himself, but to feed a starving runaway convict (Great Expectations). Once food is seen for what it is – nourishing, tasty, a source of pleasure and celebration with friends – treating any part of it as somehow inherently wicked becomes both impossible and heartless.

Not for some of the great children’s writers though. It’s hard on Edmund, in The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe, that while his sister Lucy can safely be treated to tea and toast by a faun, he unwittingly seals his pact with the White Witch by accepting the treats she offers. (‘He had the look of one who had been with the Witch and eaten her food,’ says Mr Beaver.) The drink – ‘very sweet and foamy and creamy’ – is enchanted, of course, so no ordinary food; yet there’s a sense in which Edmund is being punished for enjoying it so much. And in The Magician’s Nephew, Lewis actually recreates the Garden of Eden, with poor Digory being tempted by the Witch to eat the apple from the Tree of Life (‘A terrible thirst and hunger came over him and a longing to taste that fruit’) rather than bring it, as instructed, to Aslan.

Do modern children’s books put their heroes through this kind of Food As Temptation ordeal? My impression is not, and a good thing too. Far better for the smells and tastes of delicious things to be celebrated, so encouraging a healthy relationship with eating, rather than treated as a test for your characters to fail, as some of the children in Roald Dahl's Charlie and the Chocolate Factory do, or the ever-hungry Dick in Enid Blyton's The Faraway Tree. Surely in our more secular age we can dispense with this biblical sense of guilt surrounding food.

Naughty but Nice
Hmm. Not as simple as that. The popular culture young readers are growing into lays a heavy burden of blame on delectable goodies, from Salman Rushdie’s famous Naughty But Nice advertising slogan for cream cakes to Slimming World’s use of the term ‘syns’ for treats (short for ‘synergy’, I know, but that fools nobody).

We may no longer believe literally in the idea of Forbidden Fruit; but we're a long way from being free of its power. And on that note... excuse me while I dive into a vat of chocolate. 

Happy Easter, all!


Susan Price said…
Happy chocolate diving, Griselda! I have a buttered hot-cross bun at the ready myself.
Lydia Bennet said…
I've always been uneasy about C S Lewis and his attitude to pleasure (and sexuality) in the series. Eg susan being effectively punished and shamed by the narrator for a totally natural teenage interest in clothes and make up etc. Very puritanical, public school cold showers kind of stuff. Blyton understood how much children like food which is why there's lots of it in her books, and a much better writer, Ransome, goes into lots of meal details and how they make them, in the Swallows and Amazons books.
Bill Kirton said…
Very enjoyable and instructive, Griselda (the best sort of writing). Thank you.
Anonymous said…
Thank you all for your kind words - glad it sparked a few thoughts. I do count C S Lewis as one of the greats and I loved him as a child (probably shows in my posts!) but I agree about problem areas, especially with Susan. A strangely puritanical and judgemental attitude, clearly to do with his own sexual hangups and inhibitions. It didn't bother me at the time, as one always much preferred Lucy to Susan anyway, but it did later. All writers have their flaws I guess and C S Lewis spent much of his life as a rather crusty bachelor.

Popular posts

What's the Big Idea? - Nick Green

A Few Discreet Words About Caesar's Penis--Reb MacRath

The Splendid Rage of Harlan Ellison - Umberto Tosi

Misogyny and Bengali Children’s Poetry by Dipika Mukherjee

A Glittering Gem of Black, Gothic Humour: Griselda Heppel is intrigued by O Caledonia by Elspeth Barker