Perspectives by Sandra Horn
A while ago, I submitted two poems for an anthology on Age.
I am Of A Certain Age myself, and was under the (mistaken, as it turned out) impression that it would be celebrating agedness. I was delighted when one poem was accepted. Then, when the proofs came, it was only too evident that the focus was on loss, dementia, incontinence, death...very good poems, I must say, but not exactly joyful. I went to the launch with some trepidation and discovered two things: the guest editor had been working with people with dementia, and I was, by a stretch, the oldest poet there. It made me remember that when one is surrounded by the less happy aspects of life, perspectives, inevitably, become skewed. No-one there had met my sparky mother, dignified, in control, and sharp as a tack until she closed her eyes for the last time at age 93. Or my friend Alice, who lived to 105 and was equally ‘with-it’ to the end. They didn’t know about the woman who has just passed grade 6 ballet at the age of 71. They were looking at old age from the perspectives of its sadder aspects. I wouldn’t want to deny that there are aspects of old age that are often challenging, tragic, but that is so very far from the whole story. It partly depends on where you’re standing – too close to the sad parts of ageing for the editor, or too far distant from the lived experience of being older for the younger poets.
I am Of A Certain Age myself, and was under the (mistaken, as it turned out) impression that it would be celebrating agedness. I was delighted when one poem was accepted. Then, when the proofs came, it was only too evident that the focus was on loss, dementia, incontinence, death...very good poems, I must say, but not exactly joyful. I went to the launch with some trepidation and discovered two things: the guest editor had been working with people with dementia, and I was, by a stretch, the oldest poet there. It made me remember that when one is surrounded by the less happy aspects of life, perspectives, inevitably, become skewed. No-one there had met my sparky mother, dignified, in control, and sharp as a tack until she closed her eyes for the last time at age 93. Or my friend Alice, who lived to 105 and was equally ‘with-it’ to the end. They didn’t know about the woman who has just passed grade 6 ballet at the age of 71. They were looking at old age from the perspectives of its sadder aspects. I wouldn’t want to deny that there are aspects of old age that are often challenging, tragic, but that is so very far from the whole story. It partly depends on where you’re standing – too close to the sad parts of ageing for the editor, or too far distant from the lived experience of being older for the younger poets.
I wrote the poem – the ‘in my head’ bit before editing,
re-editing, etc. - on the ferry between Hurst Castle and Keyhaven. It’s a great
walk along the Spit to the castle, and a short-and-sweet ride back on the
little ferry. Two things enchanted me on the way back: one was a row of
beautiful identical white boats, tethered to mooring buoys and making that lovely
tinkle-clank noise in the breeze. They were called, Skugga, Sylphe, Seren Wen
and Sea Eagle. Seren Wen is Welsh for
evening star and Skugga is Faroese for cloud, I discovered later. The second
thing was a kite surfer; a gorgeous muscular young man, who came alongside and
then soared up and over the ferry. A nice piece of showing-off that brought a
smile to my face. My spirits were lifted along with the kite and I was reminded
strongly of a friend, who, well into her eighties and physically frail, said, one
day, out of the blue, ‘Inside this old woman is young girl dancing.’ Here’s the
poem in its original form:
On the ferry
The ferry chugs unhurried through the bay.
To our left, the shingle bank;
To the right, a row of tethered boats,
Skugga, Sylphe, Sea Eagle, Seren Wen,
Tug at their moorings in the salty wind.
Kite surfer skims the shallow sea,
Comes alongside, keeps pace with us,
Then makes a half-turn, lifts –
And flies. Over the ferry,
Over Sea Eagle, Skugga, Sylphe and Seren Wen.
Oh, I am nudging threescore years and ten,
Slack-fleshed, stiff-jointed,
Needing to feel my feet flat on the ground;
But now I’m up there with the surfer – past him –
Riding the wind on strong and tireless arms.
The ferry chugs below.
Skugga and Sylphe, Sea Eagle, Seren Wen
Clatter and tug and fret;
Sea-bound. Earth-bound, while I surf the sky.
I am the woman on the chugging ferry.
I am a freed Sea Eagle, sky-bound Skugga, floating
Sylphe, a shining Seren Wen.
When it was
published, in The Emma Press Anthology of Age, it didn’t have the final two
lines as the editor thought they didn’t
add anything. I’ve put them back, here, not to argue with the editorial advice,
but to underline my feelings and thoughts on that day, in that moment. It is
simply a hymn of thankfulness for undimmed youthful oomph in an ageing body,
which is pretty common amongst my venerable acquaintances. The anthology had a
stonking review in Cadaverine (yes, really) Magazine. The reviewer picked my
poem out as her favourite. Joy! Amazed delightedness! Cor, blimey! She saw
intimations of mortality in it that I hadn’t seen or meant, though. I don’t know
who she is but I’m willing to bet that she is young. Young in body, I mean. She
won’t yet know about the dancer inside – the unageing dancer.
My own very particular favourite in the anthology is by Joan
Lennon. It is written from yet another perspective on oldness – a much, much
longer view. I find it profoundly
joyful. Here it is, with Joan’s permission.
Later
Warm wool of moor
wraps the hills –
black feathered
trees
a touch of frippery
to soften old shoulders –
the long day
paled to pink
though flame remembered
still,
in touches
in shadows,
umber, amber, ochre
aged together
to a comfortable communion –
this old earth
that old sun.
Wow! Joan – and thank you!
Comments
PS. I've looked again and cannot believe how the editor couldn't see how that last line isn't just tacked on but takes up line 4 of verse 1 and the last line of 2 and turns them into that extraordinary affirmation. I think it's a great poem and (dare I say it) far better than the winner. That says 'old is old'. Yours says 'old is young,' which of course it should be.
It's quite a long poem but have a look at the first verse:
"What do you see, nurses, what do you see?
Are you thinking, when you look at me —
A crabby old woman, not very wise,
Uncertain of habit, with far-away eyes,
Who dribbles her food and makes no reply,
When you say in a loud voice — “I do wish you’d try.”
And these lines further down:
"Is that what you’re thinking, is that what you see?
Then open your eyes, nurse, you’re looking at ME…"
It's worth reading the whole poem, although you might be in tears by the end.
A little story: I recently phoned the gym I used to belong to, to enquire about rejoining. I am quite fit and strong but said, joking, "I'm over sixty now, so are there concessions for the ancient, like me?" - The woman on the other end immediately switched into an exaggeratedly saccharine, slow, enunciated manner: "Oh, bless!" (She really did say this.) "We don't, but I'll see what I can do, just for you."
I almost guffawed in her ear. I could hardly believe it. Seconds before, when I'd been explaining that I used to be a member but dropped out because of work-pressure, she'd spoken to me in a completely normal way. But as soon as I mentioned my age, I apparently became scarcely able to understand her or ask for me porridge. - I'll know not to make that joke again.
Sandra, I loved both poems - yours and Joan's - and I share the outrage at the editor's removal of your last lines. And the dancer inside...yes. Until last year I was a dancer on the outside: a member of a group of older circle dancers that met once a week. Then our teacher had to retire, and we've been unable to find anyone else to take us on. We meet for tea and cake, but it's not the same. I'd been circle dancing nearly every week for 26 years! Our ages range from 60s to 90s and we will always be dancing inside.
PS
And the poem I have come to HATE is Dylan Thomas "Do not go gentle into the good night."